FedNow vs Paypal – How Does FedNow Impact Paypal?

Over the last two decades, PayPal has led the payment processing industry. The Federal Reserve’s new instant payment service, FedNow, poses a formidable challenge to PayPal’s business model.

FedNow launched in July 2023. As a result of the launch of this service, more bank failures have occurred, and there are expectations that they will continue to rise.

What is FedNow?

Federal Reserve’s FedNow is a real-time payment system that facilitates faster bank payments for financial institutions of any size in any community. In contrast, PayPal, Venmo, Cash App, and Zelle are nonbank “closed loop” systems. There is a big difference between these services and FedNow regarding processing payments. 

The FedNow service allows near-instantaneous payments, while PayPal and other third-party companies take several days or longer.

FedNow and PayPal differ not only in terms of speed but also in terms of transaction fees and security protocols. Although both charge transaction fees, FedNow charges lower than PayPal and other third-party services. FedNow utilizes advanced encryption technologies that offer excellent fraud protection over PayPal and other third-party services. 

Also, Read | FedNow Stock: How to Buy FedNow Stocks?

How Does FedNow Impact Paypal?

There are several ways FedNow, the new instant payment service launched by the Federal Reserve, can impact PayPal’s US market business model.

Payment processing timelines

The FedNow service allows banks to send and receive payments instantly, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. It’s an interesting improvement since it’s how it works in the Bitcoin and cryptocurrency sector (for the most part). 

This is much faster than PayPal, which typically processes payments within 1-3 business days. Payments can be processed quickly, instantly, but transfers to banks can take several days, depending on the choice you make.

Consumers and businesses will likely prefer instant payment methods over PayPal due to this difference in processing timelines.

Transaction fees

There is still too much uncertainty about FedNow’s transaction fees. They will likely be less expensive than PayPal’s transaction fees. 

This is because FedNow is a government service, and governments generally have lower overhead costs than private businesses. The reality, however, is often different. Across the board, there is evidence of government excess, so it will be interesting to see if these transaction costs decrease.

The lower transaction fees offered by FedNow may make FedNow more attractive to consumers and businesses, thereby reducing PayPal’s demand.

Security Protocols

FedNow will follow the same security protocols as Fedwire. Many security protocols are used worldwide, but these are among the most secure. PayPal also protects the data of its customers with multiple security protocols. FedNow’s security protocols may be more secure than PayPal’s, giving banks a competitive advantage.

Historical trends in payment innovations

The consumer market has historically embraced new payment technologies quickly. Since the turn of the century, credit and debit cards have become increasingly popular. FedNow is likely to be accepted by consumers if it offers convenient and secure payment options.

The rapid shift toward digital payments

There is a rapid shift towards digital payments in the global payments industry. Several factors are driving this trend, including the growing popularity of online shopping and the increasing use of smartphones. Paypal must innovate and keep improving to benefit from this move toward digital payments.

Also, Read | What is GabPay? Is it an Alternative To Paypal?

Will FedNow Dominate the Global Payments System?

Probably not in the near future. There is no doubt that FedNow will significantly impact the global payments system, but financial institutions will take years to test and adopt the platform fully.

It is required that FedNow be fully adopted by the participating institutions before they can opt in, begin testing it out, and make modifications to their systems.

Some banks will likely want to wait and see how adoption goes for the early volunteers in this summer’s launch. When the service launches in late July, you won’t see any immediate changes to your bank’s ability to send and receive money.

“The go-live date is approaching, so financial institutions and their industry partners can confidently move forward with plans to join the FedNow Service network,” Ken Montgomery, FedNow program executive and first vice president at the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston said on June 29.

Will FedNow Replace Cash?

There is no chance of FedNow replacing the dollar or any other form of digital currency, for that matter. It works similarly to popular money apps in that you can transfer dollars online. FedNow promises to allow financial institutions to transfer funds between bank accounts quickly and easily.

As claimed on YouTube, TikTok, and other social media, FedNow will not replace the dollar with a new digital currency.

Also, Read | How do I Pay My Cricket Phone Bill with PayPal? – Guide

Will FedNow Create a Digital Currency?

According to critics, FedNow will create a digital currency, but the Fed has flatly denied this claim, saying, “FedNow will not create a digital currency.”.

There are separate discussions about whether the Fed should create a central bank digital currency (CBDC). There has been no decision by the Fed on issuing a CBDC, and it will “only issue a CBDC with legislation authorizing its issuance.”

According to the Atlantic Council, more than 100 nations are exploring CBDCs, including the Bahamas, China, India, and Nigeria.

Many countries are considering whether a central bank digital currency could make funds transfers safer and faster. Some consider offering CBDCs as fiat money to the public, with the accounts held at commercial or central banks.

Competition Poses Challenge to PayPal

The payment processing industry has seen several big tech companies enter recently, including Apple and Google. Due to their resources, these companies can invest heavily in new payment technologies, giving them an advantage over PayPal.

It is also challenging PayPal’s business model that big tech firms such as Apple Pay are now entering the payment processing industry. 

They have leveraged their existing customer base to gain market share in digital payments with their solutions, including Apple Pay Cash and Google Pay Send. Moreover, consumers prefer digital payments over traditional methods such as cash or checks because they are convenient and easy to use.

FAQs

Is FedNow replacing PayPal?

According to the Fed, FedNow is not intended to replace other options for money transfers like Venmo, Cash App, PayPal, or Zelle. It is intended to complement the current private sector-built systems.

How does FedNow impact PayPal?

The value proposition of PayPal’s user acquisition may need to be clarified with FedNow, but it may prove sticky to current users. The network effects of PayPal will be reduced since it is a third-party instant settlement network. This suggests the shares are overvalued and could fall by 25% + further.

What are the benefits of FedNow?

FedNow will be a service that settles and clears online payments instantly. Banks on both ends of a transaction can instantly provide each other with associated information and transfer money between relevant accounts for customers.